Roundtable Extra: Trump and the Jews
In David Rubin’s newest book Trump and the Jews, he explains the complicated nature of the small, but highly influential American Jewish community, its natural, yet uneasy relationship with the State of Israel, and the role of religious Jews (as well as Christians) in passionate support of Trump, and of Israel. It also explores the sharp American political divide, in which the role of American Jews is clearly evolving in ways that will surprise many objective observers. One thing is for sure – Donald J. Trump will continue to make headlines and the Jews will continue to be involved.
Here’s an excerpt:
“We have an interesting popular expression in Israel: “Is it good for the Jews?” Whenever something momentous happens in the world, that question can be heard in the streets of Israel. In fact, when Benjamin (Bibi) Netanyahu was elected prime minister years ago, one of his campaign slogans was, “Bibi – Good for the Jews.”
Many American Jews would find that expression appalling – after all, isn’t it excessively parochial to talk that way? Or perhaps paranoid? Those are actually very reasonable questions. Do the Jewish people, who have given so much to the betterment of civilization, actually care only about themselves?
The answer to all of those questions is a resolute “No”. After two thousand years of exile from the Land of Israel, the Jews have come home as a nation, returning to sovereignty in the Jewish homeland once again, but the trauma of our precarious existence in other people’s lands has caused us, by necessity, to view every event through the prism of our difficult history. It’s an essential survival skill that we have developed over the years. Exiled by the Romans from our country, subsequent mass beheadings of Jews on the Arabian Peninsula by Muslims, exiles and forced conversions in Spain and Portugal, followed by pogroms in Russia and the Holocaust in Europe – the threats to Jewish existence have always seemed ever-present. It certainly hasn’t been easy. Nonetheless, the Jewish people have survived all of this and have even returned, in fulfillment of biblical prophecy, to reestablish Israel as a nation in its ancestral land.
Many Jewish Americans identify as Jews by religion only and squirm at any mention of a Jewish nation, but most Israelis and many religious Jews in the United States would disagree, not seeing any contradiction between those two identities.
While not a Jew by any definition, Donald J. Trump is a New Yorker in the truest sense of the word. The accent, the style, the brashness, and the chutzpah – all stereotypes of the outer-borough New Yorkers – for good and for bad. The outer boroughs always radiated ethnicity, with a vast mix of immigrants from around the world. Trump’s parents descended from Germany and Scotland, but many of his neighbors in the borough of Queens were Jews with family roots in Russia, Poland, Romania, and other countries.
Trump’s deep connection with the Jewish people goes way back to his childhood and his father’s building projects in some very Jewish neighborhoods, but it continued in his own career as a developer of massive building projects in Manhattan and other venues, and it continues to this day. What president has ever had a Jewish convert daughter, a Jewish son-in-law, and Jewish grandchildren? All that being said, why are so many American Jews in a state of panic over his presidency? Why are so many Jews actively involved in opposing his presidency with a passion that is the polar opposite of what most Israeli Jews are feeling? Last but not least, why are so many American Orthodox Jews such enthusiastic supporters? How can we explain all of these seeming contradictions?
Just in the first half of his presidency, Trump has managed to be called virtually every curse spoken on the streets of his native New York City – from racist to sexist to anti-Semite and white supremacist. Can he really be an anti-Semite given his obvious respect and affection for the State of Israel? Can he really be an anti-Semite with all of his Jewish friends, family, and close business associates? Are those charges mere politically-based slander or is there substance to them? In Trump and the Jews, we will answer those questions as we explore the complexities of Donald J. Trump. Simultaneously, we will examine and try to understand the behavior and actions of the even more complex Jewish people, both in America and in Israel. Hopefully, by the end of Trump and the Jews, we will understand why so many Jews seem to instinctively hate Trump or love Trump. We will also understand why most Jews did not vote for him. These insights are invaluable for the many conservative or centrist Americans, who often are baffled by the Left-wing views of so many in the Jewish community, as reflected in ideological organizations like the ACLU, or in the passionately liberal elites of Hollywood. Most importantly, American Jews will read this book and will begin to base their opinions, for or against, on the reality of the Trump presidency, not on which political club they belong to. We Jews are known to be an intelligent, educated, and rational people, so especially for us, excessive name-calling and hyperbole should be inappropriate. In short, let’s explore the facts together, and then judge President Trump by the results of his presidency.”
David Rubin is a former mayor of Shiloh, Israel – in the region of Samaria, which together with Judea, is known to much of the world as the West Bank. He is founder and president of Shiloh Israel Children’s Fund (SICF) – dedicated to healing the trauma of child victims of terrorist attacks, as well as rebuilding the biblical heartland of Israel through the children. SICF was established after Rubin and his three-year-old son were wounded in a vicious terrorist attack while driving home from Jerusalem. Rubin vowed to retaliate – not with hatred, nor with anger, but with compassion – to create positive change for Israel and its children.
Rubin has become an unofficial spokesman for Israel and the biblical heartland of Israel, with his books that speak the truth about what’s really happening in Israel and the Middle East. Rubin also has written extensively about the Israel US relationship, as well as the very real threat of Jihadist Islam to Judeo-Christian civilization. These books have included, “The Islamic Tsunami: Israel and America in the Age of Obama”, and “Peace For Peace”.